Short answer: nobody can tell you which one saves more in your house, because this comparison cites no independent, side-by-side field study of Nest and ecobee. What exists is each company’s own savings claim, measured by its own method, plus a shared ENERGY STAR certification that both meet. So the useful question is not which number is bigger but which thermostat fits your equipment and habits, since savings come mostly from the schedule you run.
This comparison sticks to what each maker publishes and what ENERGY STAR requires. It lays the two sets of claims next to each other, explains why they cannot be ranked, and then gives decision rules based on wiring, heat pumps, sensors, and how much you want automated.
- No independent head-to-head field comparison of Nest and ecobee is cited here, so ‘which saves more’ has no honest numeric answer.
- Google’s 10-12% heating and 15% cooling and ecobee’s up to 26% are manufacturer claims from different methods, and ecobee says its figure is not independently verified. [1] [2]
- Both are ENERGY STAR certified, which requires at least 8% heating and 10% cooling runtime reduction at the lower confidence limit. [3]
- Choose on compatibility, heat pump support, sensors and your schedule discipline.
The two savings claims side by side
Nest (Google). Google says that on average customers save 10-12% on heating and 15% on cooling after a Nest thermostat is installed, which it translates to $131-145 a year at typical energy costs, with a payback in under 2 years. It describes the basis as an examination of bills from customers in 41 states before and after installation. [2] This is a manufacturer claim.
ecobee. ecobee advertises that its customers in North America saved up to 26% on heating and cooling costs, a figure drawn from an in-house review. The footnote on its own page states that the method has not yet undergone independent third-party verification. [1] The product page for the Smart Thermostat Premium carries the same headline, up to 26% with an asterisk. [4] This is also a manufacturer claim, and the company says so itself.
Why you cannot rank these numbers
One figure is an average across customers, split by heating and cooling. The other is an upper figure (“up to”) from the company’s own review. They come from different years, different customer bases, and different calculations. A top-of-range number will always exceed an average, which says nothing about the product behind it. Comparing 26% with 10-12% is like comparing a best day with a typical one. [1] [2]
What is the same: certification and mechanism
Both brands were among the first thermostats certified under the ENERGY STAR smart thermostat specification. [5] To earn the label, a product must show that the lower 95% confidence limit of its weighted national average runtime reduction is at least 8% for heating and 10% for cooling. [3] That is the only like-for-like benchmark the two share, and both pass it.
Both also save energy the same way: they ease off heating and cooling when you do not need it, using schedules, an app, and automatic detection of an empty home. [5] For an independent reference point, a Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory simulation found that on average 5-10% energy savings are possible, with some homes able to exceed 20% but probably with some discomfort to the occupants. [6]
The thermostat is the tool, and your setpoints are the lever.

Where they differ in practice
Differences that can affect your decision are mostly about fit and features. Verify each on the maker’s current compatibility pages, since models and revisions change.
Heat pump support. ecobee’s product page lists heat pump compatibility as 2H/2C plus 2 stage auxiliary heat. [4] For Nest models, run Google’s compatibility checker against your wire labels, since support is model-specific. For any heat pump, DOE warns against setbacks that trigger backup electric-resistance heating, so the thermostat’s heat pump logic matters. [7]
Seasonal and automatic features. Google describes a Seasonal Savings feature that adjusts schedules and reports an average of about 3 to 7% on cooling and 3 to 8% on heating, depending on the climate where users live. [2] That is another manufacturer figure and an average, not a promise.
Warranty. ecobee lists a 3-year limited warranty for the Premium model. [4] Compare it with the current Google terms on the model you are considering, and look at what the warranty excludes.
Sensors and rooms. Check whether each model supports remote room sensors, which let the thermostat respond to a room other than the hallway. How many are included, and how they are priced, changes with each model, so compare the bundle and not just the thermostat.
Privacy and accounts. Remote control and reports on smart thermostats generally rely on a cloud account and a phone app, so check how each model handles this. If you care about where your home’s occupancy and temperature data goes, read each company’s current privacy terms before you buy, and check what still works if your Wi-Fi goes down. A thermostat that keeps its local schedule during an outage is worth more than one that stops following its plan when the connection drops.
A decision flow that does not depend on brand claims
Work down this list and stop at the first rule that decides it for you.
- Does the compatibility checker approve your system? If one brand fails on your wiring (no common wire, line voltage, unusual stages), that settles it.
- Do you have a heat pump with auxiliary heat? Choose the model whose published support matches your exact stage count, and confirm how it avoids switching on backup heat during recovery. [7]
- Do you want sensors for a problem room? Pick whichever bundle includes sensors at a price you accept.
- Which phone ecosystem do you use daily? An app you like is an app you will open, and the schedule only saves energy if you maintain it.
- Is price the tie-breaker? Then compare the cost of the thermostat plus sensors against your own annual heating and cooling spend, as below.
Do the savings math with your own bills
ENERGY STAR says almost half of the annual household energy bill goes to heating and cooling, more than $900 a year. [8] Use your own figure instead of that average. As a hypothetical, suppose heating and cooling cost you $1,500 a year, and you assume a conservative 5% saving from the low end of the LBL range. That works out to a saving of $75 a year, so a hypothetical entry-level thermostat pays back in two years and a hypothetical pricier kit with sensors takes longer. [6]
Run the same example at 10% and the payback halves, which shows how sensitive it is to the assumption. This is why the manufacturer ranges, up to 26% for one and 10-12% plus 15% for the other, should not drive the decision. [1] [2]
If your heating and cooling spend is small, because you have a mild climate or a very efficient house, neither thermostat will pay for itself quickly.

FAQ
Is ecobee better than Nest?
Neither is shown to be better by any independent comparison cited here. ecobee advertises savings of up to 26% with a footnote that the method lacks third-party verification, while Google reports 10-12% on heating and 15% on cooling from customer bills. [1] [2] These are different measures.
Do both work with heat pumps?
Heat pump support depends on the model and your auxiliary heat stages. ecobee lists 2H/2C plus 2 stage auxiliary heat for its Premium model. [4] Run each maker’s compatibility checker.
Will either one pay for itself?
It depends on your heating and cooling spend and your old habits. Google claims a payback of under 2 years, which is a manufacturer claim. [2] Do your own arithmetic with your bills.
Are both ENERGY STAR certified?
Both were among the first brands certified under the smart thermostat specification. [5] Confirm the specific model you buy is on the current certified list.
Switch off power to the heating and cooling system before touching thermostat wiring, never put a low-voltage thermostat on a line-voltage circuit, and call a licensed professional if wiring is unfamiliar. Every savings number for these two brands is a manufacturer claim or a simulation, not a measurement of your home.
Sources
- Savings from your ecobee | ecobee. ecobee (manufacturer claims), accessed 2026-10-12
- Improve energy savings with your Nest thermostat | Google Nest Help. Google Nest (manufacturer claims), accessed 2026-10-12
- Smart Thermostats Key Product Criteria | ENERGY STAR. U.S. EPA ENERGY STAR, accessed 2026-10-12
- Smart Thermostats (Smart Home Tips) | ENERGY STAR. U.S. EPA ENERGY STAR, accessed 2026-10-12
- Simulation-Driven Rating of Smart Thermostats | LBNL. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, accessed 2026-10-12
- Tips on Saving Money and Energy in Your Home (Energy Saver Guide, 2022). U.S. Department of Energy, accessed 2026-10-12
- Smart Thermostats | ENERGY STAR. U.S. EPA ENERGY STAR, accessed 2026-10-12
Savings, costs and rebate figures are estimates from the dated sources cited on each page; your results depend on your home, climate and utility rates, and incentive programs change often. Gas, venting and electrical work belongs with a licensed professional. This is general information, not financial, tax or legal advice. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.